Us Against Them!

“I am sick and tired of being called derogatory names,” bemoaned my friend. 
“Just because I believe in traditional marriage, that doesn’t make me a homophobe. If  I say I am against killing the unborn, that doesn’t mean I am against women exercising their rights. I have no problem with immigrants. For God’s sake, I am an immigrant myself. However, I am against illegal immigration. Why should that make me a xenophobe? I am NOT a racist when I talk about the absence of fathers in the black community. Don’t these people realize that all this name-calling prevents us from having civil conversations that may result in solving some of these issues?” 
His woes reminded me of what we, the followers of Christ, for years, have done to ourselves, and those outside the church. 
If you attended a white evangelical church, you had to be a Republican. No Democrat could survive the criticism in those churches. On the other hand, in a black church, you were an Uncle Tom if you were a Republican. Today, this attitude is fiercer than ever before. I have Christian friends who have cut off relationships with other Christians purely for political reasons. 
The sins of the church toward “outsiders” are many. Once a year, my friend, Pastor Phil, sets up a tent in a public place and uses it as a confessional booth. Inside the tent he dresses up as a monk and when people walk in to confess, he is the one who confesses the sins of the church to them. I am no Phil, so I limit my confession of the churches’ sin to only one example. 
For years, the church singled out the gay community and pounded on them. We would more readily accept a supposed repented murderer to our fellowship than a Christian gay man/woman who has spent a lifetime serving God with all sincerity while struggling with his/her sexuality. We’d be more willing to listen to any sexual struggles a heterosexual might have with his/her sins, but hardly ever willing to hear of the struggles of a gay man or woman. 
And by doing so, we have created a culture of “US” (the righteous Christians) against “THEM” (those who don’t agree with us, the righteous Christians. 
The fact that those who are in Christ are called righteous is a biblical reality (2 Cor. 5:21). However, according to Jesus, the righteous person is poor, humiliated, desperate, hungry, thirsty, persecuted and… (Matthew 5:1-12)  But, even more important, this righteousness or rightness with God isn’t the result of some personal achievement.  As Tugwell says, 

…the trouble with their (Pharisees) outstanding righteousness was that, all too easily, it could be viewed precisely measured, so that at the certain point, you could say that you had now achieved it. This meant that it could all too easily come adrift from its original inspiration in devotion to God and become self-sufficient.
It is against this self-achieved and measurable righteousness that Jesus speaks of.  The self-righteousness that proudly stands up and proclaims, “God, I thank you that I am not like those people…” Luke 18:12—The kind of self-righteousness that sets US against THEM.  
Let there be no misunderstanding. I strongly believe in right vs. wrong. Unlike some who accuse others of intolerance because the so called, “intolerant” happens to distinguish between good and evil, I believe in being objective distinguishing between right and wrong. However, my objectiveness and effort in doing right doesn’t make me MORE righteous. As I remember, Jesus said something like, after doing all that we should have done and refrained from all that we should have refrained from, we’re still useless servants. What conveys the above humble attitude must be the way we communicate what we believe.
For example, I believe the definition of marriage should be reserved for a union between a man and a woman. Putting the Bible aside, this has been a universal truth that every society, culture and ethnicity has believed and practiced since the beginning of time.  In an ideal world, my definition of marriage should not set me against those who don’t agree with me, but we don’t live in that world yet. Because of what I just said, the reality is that many will call me names like homophobe, xenophobe, racist and… That I can’t help, but the way I react to those who don’t agree with me is something I CAN control.  And this is where I’ve so often come short forgetting that ultimately, as a follower of Christ, my goal must be winning people’s hearts and souls and not an argument. 
—————————— 
It’s a day before the election in California. The fate of Prop 8  (The proposition against same sex marriage) is going to be decided tomorrow. As I’m opening my living room windows facing the street, I notice my neighbor, Ted, walking his dog. Ted and Eric (not their real names) are our gay neighbors whom we’ve know for the last 24 years. They’ve been together longer than many Christian couples I know.  We have been to each other’s homes for dinner many times and have a good relationship.
“Hey Ted, I just wanted you to know how I’m going to vote on Prop 8 tomorrow,” I screamed out of the window.
If you know me, you know that I’m one of the most transparent people you ever come across—and sometimes to a fault. And this was one of those times. In my way of thinking, I wanted my neighbor, the person I have know for a few years now, love and have a very high respect for to know where I stood. This was my way of saying, 
“Thank you for accepting me as a friend even though we don’t agree on this subject.”
Ted laughed and says something like, “Shah, we all know how you’re going to vote.” And walked away.

About a year later, as Karen and I sitting in Ted and Eric’s living room waiting for dinner to be served, Eric, Ted’s partner, very sternly faced me and with tears in his eyes said, 
“What do you have against me marrying this man that I love so much?”
The question completely catches me by surprise. I’m blindsided and was at loss for words. His crying makes me cry.  I’m suddenly faced with the fact that my statement of a year ago, how be it, coming from a very innocent and pure motive, has hurt people I care for.  It’s very easy to disagree with nameless or faceless “Them” out there, but it is a whole different world when those “Them” are your friends. 
“I have nothing against you getting married. My opposition is to changing the definition of marriage,“ I respond
“What do you mean, “ he demands while crying.
“By changing the definition, we’re opening the Pandora’s box which will come back to haunt us.”
“No! It won’t.”
As much as I care for this couple (and they know it), and as much as I do not want to see my friends hurt or upset by/with me, I have to stand up for my convections/values. And so does he, for that matter. 
We go on crying and arguing. 
At the end, we come to the conclusion that we’re not about to change each other’s mind, so with my wife and Eric watching us rather uncomfortably, we hugged and sat down to eat dinner. I love Ted and Eric not because they agree or disagree with me, but because they’re my friends made in God’s image.
A few years later, when Prop 8 is overturned by the Supreme Court, as much as I disagree with the decision, I text Ted with one word, “Congratulation!”
———————————
I’ll leave you with these words,
To the Christian community, expressing God’s love towards those with whom we disagree should not be confused with agreement with their point of view. While we should hold firm to our Judeo-Christian principles, we must continue to love because Christ commanded us to do so.
To the gay community, please don’t reject me because I am willing to tolerate you, but not celebrate you. As much as I detest using the word, “tolerate” within the context of this article (It sounds like painfully putting up with something or someone, which is not my intention at all) I am using it because, strangely enough, it is a very acceptable word within the gay community. I may disagree with your point of view, but I am NOT against you as a person.
And this, my friends, is the key to a civil discourse.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Us Against Them!

  1. You asked me to read, and so I am.

    You’re probably aware from my post you commented on, but if not, I do greatly disagree with you on the subject of gay marriage. I could argue with you on this, but you’ve probably heard them all, from the historical implications of Leviticus to civil vs. religious marriages.

    What I do agree with you on is how you go about things. You disagree with it the viewpoint / practice and vote according to your beliefs, and I respect that. I admit I find it hard not to outright dislike you for it, but I’m trying to temper that and not rush to judgement.

    In a way this is related to my post. People rush to judgement, correctly or not. It’s human nature, and it’s not an easy thing to learn to stop and reserve that judgement until you have further information. I still can’t blame that group for rushing to judgement on my behavior, even if it was inaccurate. I can’t imagine what they each had gone through in their lives, and so having an emotional response to my actions. I should have spoke with them then and there, apologized and explained, and not waited ten years to speak up anonymously on a blog.

    I admit that I rush to judgement a lot of times, especially dealing with religious issues. When someone admits they’re a devout Christian or a Republican or both, I immediately become wary. I hate it, in all honesty. I have friends that are Christians and do believe in gay marriage and thus I should know better. I feel that most Christians are of the ‘live and let live’ sort like you. You don’t agree with it, but you’re not going to go verbally or physically gay bashing. Unfortunately, people and groups like the Westboro Baptist Church have the loudest voice and are painting everyone with their colors.

    You and I aren’t going to agree, and that’s fine. That’s life. As long we agree to respect each other as people, or at least tolerate each other as people, we’ll be fine. And I really wish more people would realize that. Discourse and arguing is great, it’s what keeps us all growing as people, but intolerance is what destroys us as people.

    My great-grandmother used to say something that I always liked. “There’s a reason God gave you two ears and one mouth.” We should listen twice as much as we speak instead of the other way around. Maybe once we start actually listening to one another, things will work out more often. (I can’t help it, I have to hope things will get better.)

    Like

  2. Lacy, thank you for taking the time to write such a long reply. It really means a lot to me. Please allow me to answer you point by point.

    You said, “You’re probably aware from my post you commented on, but if not, I do greatly disagree with you on the subject of gay marriage. I could argue with you on this, but you’ve probably heard them all, from the historical implications of Leviticus to civil vs. religious marriages.”

    My post had nothing to do with gay marriage, but everything to do with how to disagree and still stay civil. That I can disagree with my gay neighbor, but can still love and respect him/her.

    You said, “What I do agree with you on is how you go about things. You disagree with it the viewpoint / practice and vote according to your beliefs, and I respect that. I admit I find it hard not to outright dislike you for it, but I’m trying to temper that and not rush to judgement.”

    I so admire your honest confession. Thank you! I mean that, but why would you dislike me for not agreeing with my neighbor? Why don’t you dislike my neighbor for not agreeing with me? Is it because you agree with him and not me? Or do you dislike me because I’m honest and transparent with my friends even when it might hurt their feelings? By the way, the reason for having such a relationship with my neighbors is because we have won each other’s trust. We have invested time in each other’s lives and they know I will give my life to defend their rights to get married.

    You said, “I admit that I rush to judgement a lot of times, especially dealing with religious issues. When someone admits they’re a devout Christian or a Republican or both, I immediately become wary. I hate it, in all honesty. I have friends that are Christians and do believe in gay marriage and thus I should know better. I feel that most Christians are of the ‘live and let live’ sort like you. You don’t agree with it, but you’re not going to go verbally or physically gay bashing. Unfortunately, people and groups like the Westboro Baptist Church have the loudest voice and are painting everyone with their colors.

    Interesting that you automatically connected Christians with Republicans. You be surprised how many Christian Democrat there are who don’t believe in gay marriage, but that’s not the issue here. I am so glad that you have Christian friends who are different. A true Christian is one who follows the teaching of Christ to the best of his/her ability. It is a shame that our news media is quick to report on a handful (they literally were a handful) of wacked out morons at WBC, but they hardly ever report about thousands upon thousands of Christian charities around the world. I used to oversee an orphanage in Tajikistan. Do you know where that is?

    You said, “You and I aren’t going to agree, and that’s fine. That’s life. As long we agree to respect each other as people, or at least tolerate each other as people, we’ll be fine. And I really wish more people would realize that. .”

    Hey, I’ve been married to the love of my life for 40 years and we still don’t agree on everything, so why should that be any better between you and me who’ve never met 😉 I couldn’t have said it better. You do have a great way with words, “Discourse and arguing is great, it’s what keeps us all growing as people, but intolerance is what destroys us as people.” We do have a lot more in common than you think.

    You had/have a wise grandma. The Bible says, “Even a fool looks wise when he keeps his mouth shut.” Thank you for allowing me to write this long reply. Looking forward to reading your next post. Have a good evening.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s